Why America Is "Tech Hoarding" — and It's Not the Economy

If you’re like most of us, you probably have a junk drawer — or box, or bin, or dedicated corner of the garage. In this day and age, it might look like a graveyard of gadgets past: a tangled nest of mystery cords, chargers for long-gone devices, old phones, maybe even a stray Blu-Ray disc or flash drive.

Nobody needs tech junk, but so many of us keep it. In fact, a recent study by Secure Data found that a staggering 94% of Americans have their own hoards at home. So why is this pretty much useless stuff so hard to get rid of? Is it just that old axiom — as soon as it’s gone, you’ll suddenly need it — hanging over our heads?

While it’s easy to point fingers at economic uncertainty as a reason for holding onto, well, everything, Secure Data’s findings suggest something deeper is at play when it comes to our electronic relics. We cling to our retired tech for potential usefulness (or the illusion of it), sentimental value, and anxiety over our increasingly compromised personal data.

The “Just In Case” Thinking Trap

The most common reason cited for keeping old tech according to Secure Data’s survey is the belief that it might be useful again someday. Despite the fact that planned obsolescence is a confirmed driver of the tech industry, a whopping 69% of respondents harbor the hope that they’ll magically find new uses for their outdated devices.

This also explains why charging cords top the list of the most hoarded items, with 87% of people admitting to keeping them. Who hasn’t experienced the frustration of needing a specific, obscure charger for something that won’t power on otherwise? Other heavily hoarded items include old smartphones (79%), headphones (75%), laptops (69%), and even DVDs (74%).

The study highlights what’s probably a relatable behavior: holding onto specialty or proprietary cables for gadgets we no longer even own, just in case. It speaks to a fear of future need, the reluctance to discard something that might, theoretically, solve a problem that would otherwise be unresolvable down the line.

• Also read: Digital Fatigue: A Third of Americans Willing To Trade Security for Convenience

Never mind the fact that the corresponding device is long gone or that technology keeps marching relentlessly forward, rendering both cord and gadget obsolete. The potential utility, however slim, outweighs the need to declutter. That ancient MP3 player charger isn’t likely to bring back your listening habits from 2005, yet into the box it goes.

The Powerful Pull of Nostalgia

Following close behind the (albeit questionable) practicality of technological preparedness as a driver for tech hoarding is nostalgia. Nearly two-thirds of Americans surveyed admit that they hoard old tech because they’re attached to it and just can’t bear to let go.

Our devices aren’t just tools; they become intertwined with our memories and life experiences. That first digital camera might hold photos from a middle school modeling session. An old gaming console could evoke rainy afternoons spent having fun with siblings. A retired smartphone might contain special text messages from a loved one.

In that way, tech serves as a tangible link to our past selves and experiences. Holding onto an old camcorder isn’t just about keeping the hardware or powering it on to try using it again — it’s about preserving the feeling associated with the old home movies it captured.

In an increasingly digital and often intangible world (hello, VR), these physical artifacts — even if they no longer function — offer a comforting anchor to personal history.

Security Fears and Digital Footprints

Beyond these motives lies a decidedly modern, and perhaps more pressing, concern: personal data. The third most common reason for hoarding is the belief that the devices contain sensitive personal information.

In an era acutely aware of data breaches and identity theft, the idea of simply tossing a hard drive or old phone into the trash feels reckless. Some of us hold onto our tech simply because of the data it holds.

Secure Data also found that more than half of Americans do this even if they have their data backed up elsewhere. This points to some deeper anxieties: a lack of trust in backup methods, uncertainty about how to securely wipe a device, or maybe an unfounded bias that the original device holding the data is somehow more secure or complete than a copy.

Who among us hasn’t sweated, at least a little bit, deleting important files even after we’ve backed them up? And the process of securely erasing data can be pretty daunting itself, leading many people to just stick their devices in the drawer indefinitely.

Other Hoarding Habits

For one in two people, the hope that their old tech might be valuable in the future is enough justification to keep it. While it’s occasionally true for rare items, most mass-produced consumer electronics depreciate rapidly. Yet the “maybe someday” thought persists, fueled by stories of collectible gaming cartridges or iconic early computers.

Other common hoarding behaviors identified include keeping outdated media like CDs, DVDs, or even floppy disks (remember those?), despite over 40% of said hoarders lacking the hardware to use them. Nearly two-fifths hang onto original packaging, too, perhaps believing it enhances potential resale value or simply because it feels wrong to discard the complete set.

And then there are the eternal optimists: Nearly a third of people are saving broken tech with the intention of repairing it someday. Will that “someday” ever come? The jury’s out, but the intention is enough to keep the item from hitting the curb.

This ties back to the overarching reluctance to waste something that was probably pretty expensive to buy, or represents some kind of potential functionality, however locked away it is.

Letting Go of Devices Past

Ultimately, Secure Data’s survey shows that America’s tech hoarding habit is about far more than economic prudence. It’s a tangled web of perceived utility, nostalgia, legitimate data security fears, speculative future value, and, perhaps above all, the sheer inertia of figuring out what to do with objects we once valued.

Not to get too philosophical, but maybe discarding them feels like discarding a part of ourselves — or maybe we’re just genuinely too lazy to drag those five laptops to the one dedicated recycling plant in town.

In any case, understanding why we feel compelled to hang onto tech is the first step toward getting out from under the hoard. So the next time you try to tackle that junk drawer, think about the reasons you’re still holding on — they might just help you finally let go.

Read next: Emotional Needs Drive AI Use, Leaving Marketing Tasks Far Behind